Toxic Body Image Content for Teens on Instagram
New research exposes the prevalence of Instagram posts promoting eating disorders, plastic surgery, and skin whitening products to young women.
New research exposes the prevalence of Instagram posts promoting eating disorders, plastic surgery, and skin whitening products to young women.
With more than a billion people now using Instagram across the world, the Facebook-owned platform plays an outsized role in shaping visual norms and portraying aspirational goals for vast swathes of society today. Though this staggering degree of influence offers significant potential to enhance the public good, all too often it is used to maximise corporate profits at the expense of individual well-being and agency. Case in point: A research report commissioned by global activist group SumOfUs, which reveals the alarming degree to which content that promotes eating disorders, plastic surgery, and skin whitening products is made available on the platform to young women and teens.
Body image issues -- already highly prevalent amongst young people -- have been exacerbated by Covid-19. The number of patients ages 10 to 23 suffering from eating disorders has doubled since the start of the pandemic, and the National Eating Disorders Association in the US has seen a 40% increase in calls to its helpline since March 2020. With more time spent online, young people are increasingly susceptible to the persuasive suggestions of Instagram’s algorithms -- a manipulation machine designed to maximise engagement by amplifying content which is routinely harmful, untrue, or both. Such suggestions can be devastating on mental and physical health, with Instagram acknowledging having promoted weight loss content to people with eating disorders (unexpected triggers carry significant risk of relapse).
Aware of this highly serious issue, and unconvinced that Instagram and Facebook were taking sufficient steps to remedy it, the researchers examined 720 Instagram posts to better quantify the scale of the problem (240 posts each on eating disorders, plastic surgery, and skin whitening). Their research findings confirm that despite Facebook’s promises to curb such content, Instagram remains full of toxic posts that pose an immediate danger to the lives of those who use its services -- one heightened for teens and people of colour.
The report, Eating Disorders, Plastic Surgery, and Skin Whitening on Instagram: How young people are exposed to toxic content, highlights several key findings, including:
- 22 different hashtags were identified that promote eating disorders on Instagram, potentially leading to over 45 million eating disorder related posts.
- Of the 240 eating disorder posts analysed, 86.7% were pushing unapproved appetite suppressants, and 52.9% posts directly promoted eating disorders.
- 22 different hashtags were identified that promote plastic surgery on Instagram, potentially leading to over 22 million plastic surgery related posts.
- Of the 240 plastic surgery posts analysed, 86.7% were using posts to promote plastic surgery procedures or clinics.
- Of the 240 skin-whitening posts analysed, 81.3% promoted skin whitening products, of which 83.1% were unapproved products.
These findings dovetail with recent Wall Street Journal bombshell reporting on the significant negative impact of Instagram posts on teen girls. As revealed by the Journal, Facebook’s own internal research declared: “We make body image issues worse for one in three teen girls” and “Teens blame Instagram for increases in the rate of anxiety and depression.” Yet despite this and other critical information being made available to top executives, the company has continued to consistently target the most at-risk groups. Without regulatory intervention, Facebook simply has no financial incentive to remove the harmful content.
In response to its troubling findings, SumOfUs is calling for legislators to pass meaningful platform regulation and take action to ensure Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, TikTok, and other platforms give independent researchers access to the data they hold regarding the impact of their platforms on kids and teens.
Under the democratic banner of The People’s Declaration, the citizens of Europe have made it known that the Digital Services Act (DSA) and Digital Markets Act (DMA) must value people over profits. Findings like those in the SumOfUs report underscore the urgent need to turn off the manipulation machine. The organisations of The People's Declaration, which represent over 25 million citizens across the European Union, are firm in their conviction: “It is time for these platforms to de-risk their design, detox their algorithms, give users real control over them and be held to account for failing to do so.”
Download Eating Disorders, Plastic Surgery, and Skin Whitening on Instagram: How young people are exposed to toxic content here.
Related Articles
Briefing: protecting children and young people from addictive design
Research has shown the deep harm excessive social media use can do to young brains and bodies. The EU Commission must tackle the root cause.
Letter to European Commissioner Breton: Tackling harmful recommender systems
Civil society organisations unite behind Coimisiún na Meán’s proposal to disable profiling-based recommender systems on social media video platforms
Open letter to the European Parliament: A critical opportunity to protect children and young people
Dear Members of the European Parliament, We, experts, academics and civil society groups, are writing to express our profound alarm at the social-media driven
Most Read
Letter to European Commissioner Breton: Tackling harmful recommender systems
Civil society organisations unite behind Coimisiún na Meán’s proposal to disable profiling-based recommender systems on social media video platforms
Prototyping User Empowerment – Towards DSA-compliant recommender systems
What would a healthy social network look like? Researchers, civil society experts, technologists and designers came together to imagine a new way forward
ESC Big Tech this Black Friday
People vs Big Tech has joined forces with high street brand Lush to raise money for our work to rein in the harmful power of the Big Tech corporations