Facebook’s Climate Commitments Miss the Bigger Picture
As global leaders convene for COP26, a new report reveals the alarming growth of climate misinformation on the world’s most popular platform
As global leaders convene to set stronger emission goals at COP26, a new report reveals the alarming growth of climate misinformation on the world’s most popular platform.
Politicians and policymakers from all over the world have gathered in Glasgow for the 2021 United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP26) with the goal of establishing emission reduction standards consistent with targets from the landmark 2015 Paris Agreement. Yet while the scientific community warns strong action must be taken immediately to stem the climate crisis, the threat posed by climate change deniers is increasing with alarming speed due to the amplification of their outlier voices on online platforms. As a new report by Stop Funding Heat and the Real Facebook Oversight Board reveals, not only do climate misinformation posts rarely receive fact-checking labels on Facebook -- but views of such posts on the platform far outpace the number of visitors Facebook sends to its Climate Science Information Center to get accurate information.
Though Facebook has implemented significant sustainability policies across its operations and carbon footprint, the reality remains that climate change denial -- perhaps the largest threat to meaningful environmental progress -- continues to thrive on the platform. A recent analysis by Avaaz from May 2021 found an estimated 25 millions views on Facebook of “misinformation related to climate science and renewable energy” in the first two months of President Biden’s term alone. The constant spread of this type of toxic information plainly undermines the tech titan’s other environmental efforts and threatens to negatively impact the viability of new, large-scale climate policies such as those being discussed at COP26.
In an effort to capture the scale of this complex problem, Stop Funding Heat -- a group of concerned individuals committed to making climate misinformation unprofitable -- prepared two reports in advance of COP26. The first, On The Back Burner: How Facebook’s Inaction on Misinformation is Fueling the Climate Crisis, addressed Facebook’s lack of climate misinformation policies and the company’s failure to contain climate misinformation on its platform.
The second, #In Denial - Facebook’s Growing Friendship with Climate Misinformation, takes this analysis a step further by documenting the significant spread of misinformation across organic posts and ads on the platform. Drawing off an English-only dataset of 196 accounts and 48,700 posts from January to August 2021, the just-released report from Stop Funding Heat and the Real Facebook Oversight Board highlights several key findings, including:
- Climate misinformation posts are constantly being made and interacted with on Facebook. Across the dataset, there were 38,925 instances of climate misinformation, with 10 million combined interactions (likes, reactions, comments, and shares). Notably, interactions do not include the following engagements: link clicks, photo views, video views, or event responses.
- Climate misinformation posts are constantly being viewed on Facebook. Across the dataset, there were 818,000 to 1.36 million daily views of climate misinformation (based on a conservative interaction rate of 3 to 5%).
- Fact-checking labels are very rarely applied to climate misinformation posts. Only 3.6% of climate misinformation posts in the dataset had a fact-checking label.
- Climate misinformation posts made by news channels and news presenters serve as hotspots for interactions. Despite making up just 4% of climate misinformation posts in the dataset, posts by news channels and news presenters accounted for 67% of all interactions.
Further unpacking these numbers helps to demonstrate the extent of the problem. As the report notes, the 818,000 to 1.36 million daily views of climate misinformation are particularly troublesome because they represent 8.2x to 13.6x the number of visitors Facebook sends to its Climate Science Information Center on a daily basis (according to Facebook’s public claim that its center has “over 100,000 daily visitors”). And for some of the most problematic climate misinformation accounts (i.e., the 41 pages and groups in the dataset that exclusively post climate misinformation), engagement is growing. In January 2021, these accounts saw 165,000 interactions with their posts. By August 2021, that monthly figure had climbed to 241,000. Further muddying the waters, only 10.6% of posts in this subset included a Facebook-applied link to the Climate Science Information Center, and only 9.1% had a fact-checking label applied. That means 80% of climate misinformation posts from accounts solely dedicated to posting this type of content received no intervention from Facebook whatsoever.
In addition to profiting off increased user interactions with inflammatory posts, the report also demonstrates that Facebook continues to accept payment for climate misinformation ads. Using the Facebook Ad Library, the report identified 113 climate misinformation ads from 1 January to 17 October 2021. Facebook’s own figures estimate these ads received 11.7 million to 14.1 million views. These ads included language such as Turning Point USA’s “Climate Change Is A HOAX!” and PragerU’s “Are you fed up with the left’s dishonest climate propaganda and hysteria like Tomi Lahren is? Sign this petition to tell mainstream media to stop censoring the important work of scientists and scholars.”
To help draw attention to the report and climate misinformation crisis on Facebook, global activist group SumOfUs placed a 5,000lb block of recycled ice in front of the U.S. Capitol on 4 November. As the ice melted, Facebook’s logo and flames became increasingly apparent -- paralleling the damage being done to the planet by the company’s climate misinformation failures.
Said SumofUS campaigns advisor Rewan Al-Haddad, “The flood of disinformation unleashed by Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook is drowning audiences around the world, with more than 1.3m views of climate misinformation each day. Demanding better of Facebook only leads to more greenwashing and lies. We call for the US, UK, and the EU to stop Facebook’s unchecked power, for the sake of our climate and our collective future.”
In light of the report's findings, Stop Funding Heat is calling for Facebook to (1) go public with its definition of climate misinformation, (2) share its internal research on how climate misinformation spreads on the platform, and (3) produce a transparent plan to meaningfully reduce the spread of climate misinformation on Facebook.
Said Sean Buchan, Chief Researcher for Stop Funding Heat, “Facebook has been told over and over, through public reports and in private meetings, that its platform is a breeding ground for climate misinformation. Either they don’t care or they don’t know how to fix it.”
Download #In Denial - Facebook’s Growing Friendship with Climate Misinformation here.
Related Articles
Civil Society Organisations Call on EU Parliament to Close Disinformation Loophole
The carve-out for media in the proposed European Media Freedom Act will seriously impede efforts to combat hate speech and disinformation
A 10-point plan to address our information crisis
Nobel prize laureates Maria Ressa and Dmitry Muratov launch a roadmap for fixing our global public square
Fueled by Social Media, Calls for Violence Against Muslims Reach Fever Pitch in India
New research documents the dangerous degree to which hate speech and disinformation on Facebook are thriving. Genocide Watch warns that the “early warning
Most Read
Letter to European Commissioner Breton: Tackling harmful recommender systems
Civil society organisations unite behind Coimisiún na Meán’s proposal to disable profiling-based recommender systems on social media video platforms
Prototyping User Empowerment – Towards DSA-compliant recommender systems
What would a healthy social network look like? Researchers, civil society experts, technologists and designers came together to imagine a new way forward
ESC Big Tech this Black Friday
People vs Big Tech has joined forces with high street brand Lush to raise money for our work to rein in the harmful power of the Big Tech corporations